🪄Market the Proof: Prove that transformation is possible

Cut the Fluff is a newsletter that will help you become a more confident writer, even if you're not a "writer." If this was sent to you, subscribe here so you don't miss the next lesson.

Hey Reader,

"But will it work for ME?"

That's the question lurking in the back of everyone's mind when they're considering working with you, buying your course, or implementing your advice.

And it's a damn good question.

With so many people making wild claims online, skepticism isn't just normal — it's necessary.

Today, we’re diving into the final P of the MP3 Framework: Market the Proof.

I’m writing a 5-part series on this topic. Here’s where we’re at:

🪄 The MP3 Framework: Why content pillars are holding you back
🪄 Market the Problem: How to articulate your buyers’ problems better than they can themselves
🪄 Market the Process: Turn your experience into valuable insights
🪄 Market the Proof: Show (don’t just tell) your value (we are here)
🪄 Building your Content Engine: How Problem, Process, and Proof work together (coming next week)

Let’s quickly recap: In the MP3 Framework, instead of restricting yourself to content pillars, you focus on marketing the:

Problem (articulating your buyers’ struggles better than they can)
Process (sharing your messy, real experiences and frameworks)
Proof (validating your insights with tangible results)

You can't handle the proof!

(Actually, we can, and we demand it, but I needed to use this wordplay here, so thanks for indulging me.)

Proof content is the evidence that what you teach, offer, or provide actually works.

When you share proof in your content:

You build credibility: Anyone can claim to be an expert. Proof shows you actually know what you’re talking about. It sets you apart from the “theoretical experts” who only share opinions without showing results.
You validate your approach: When people see concrete outcomes, they’re more likely to believe your methods work.
You reduce perceived risk: You’re showing that your solution works for real people with real problems.
You create the “that could be me” effect: When someone sees results from people similar to them, they start to believe the same is possible for them.
You justify your pricing: When people can see the value you deliver, price becomes less of an objection. They understand what they’re investing in.
You build social proof: Humans are pack animals. We look to others to determine what’s worth our time and money.

Nothing sells like concrete evidence that your approach works.

Let's dive in, shall we?

5 ways to market the proof

Not all proof is created equal. Some forms of evidence are significantly more persuasive than others.

I've watched thousands of people try to prove their value online, and these five types consistently outperform the rest:

Before/after examples
Specific results with numbers
Screenshot evidence
Client success stories
Implementation examples

Let's explore why each one works so damn well.

1. Before/after examples

The human brain is wired to notice contrast. It's why weight loss programs show the same person in different states. It's why home renovation shows dedicate equal time to the "before" footage as they do the stunning reveal.

Before/after proof focuses on clear, measurable contrasts — often in a direct, side-by-side comparison format.

Think data points, visual comparisons, or measurable metrics placed in direct opposition:

LinkedIn profiles: 5 likes per post → 200+ likes per post
Websites: 2% conversion rate → 8% conversion rate
Email open rates: 22% → 42%
Client pipeline: 3 leads per month → 15 leads per month

Why is this so irresistible?

It validates both the starting point and destination: When prospects see someone who started where they are now, they feel understood. When they see where that person ended up, they feel inspired.
It compresses time: You're essentially saying, "This massive change that would normally take years happened in weeks/months* because of this approach."
It shows the proven path: We all want transformation without getting lost in dead ends or endless experimentation. Before/after proof shows you've already mapped the journey from problem to solution.

*Obviously, don't lie and say something takes weeks if it takes longer. We've got enough of those grifters online already, and the lies are icky-gross-yucky-nope.

How to make before/after proof even more powerful:

Get specific about the starting conditions: "They had been posting on LinkedIn for 8 months, averaging 5-10 likes per post with no meaningful business opportunities..."
Quantify the transformation: "...and within 45 days of implementing my content framework, their average engagement jumped to 150+ likes and 20+ comments per post."
Include the unexpected benefits: "Not only did they land 3 new clients worth $26K, but they also got invited to speak at two industry events and were approached by a podcast host."
Add emotional context: "They went from feeling like an impostor every time they hit 'post' to confidently sharing their expertise, knowing each post was strengthening their position in the market."

The best before/after proof focuses on stark, measurable contrasts that make the transformation undeniable at a glance.

2. Specific results with numbers

Specific numbers have a psychological weight that general claims can never match.

"I helped them 10X their business" sounds like marketing speak. "Their revenue went from $4,287 to $47,839 in 5 months" sounds like you're sharing actual results.

Why specific numerical proof cuts through:

It creates immediate credibility: The specificity signals that you're not exaggerating.
It sets clear expectations: Prospects can see exactly what's possible and in what timeframe.
It shifts from qualitative to quantitative: Moving from "it works well" to "it works exactly this well" changes the conversation entirely.

How to make numerical proof actually meaningful:

Use odd, precise numbers: "$9,738 in new sales" feels more believable than "$10,000 in new sales"
Include the full context: "They went from 32 leads per month to 127 leads per month with the same ad spend"
Connect multiple metrics to tell a story: "Email open rates increased from 22% to 38%, click rates from 3% to 9%, and sales from $5K to $15K per month"
Follow the money: Ultimately, show how the numbers affected what people care about most — time, money, impact, or stress.

The biggest mistake people make with numerical proof is focusing on vanity metrics without connecting them to real business outcomes. Nobody cares about your 100K impressions if you can't show what those impressions led to.

As I said a few months ago...impressions are cool, but are you making money, though?

3. Screenshot evidence

In an era where "pics or it didn't happen" has become the default response to claims, screenshots serve as digital receipts that cut through skepticism.

There's something powerfully authentic about a screenshot that even the most eloquent testimonial can't match. It's raw. It's unfiltered. It's a moment captured in its natural habitat.

Types of screenshots that create instant belief:

Unprompted client messages: When someone DMs you, "HOLY SHIT, THIS WORKED," without you asking for feedback, that spontaneous excitement is pure gold.
Revenue/results dashboards: Nothing proves your approach works like a screenshot of actual analytics showing the upward trend.
Public comments or praise: When someone publicly vouches for you, it carries more weight because they're putting their reputation on the line.
Implementation in action: Showing how clients have applied your framework in the wild proves it's practical, not just theoretical.

How to use screenshots most effectively:

Circle or highlight the key data point: Don't make people search for the important part. (Notice how I annotated my screenshot in the LinkedIn post above?)
Add context if needed: Sometimes, a brief "This client implemented the framework on Day 1 and sent me this on Day 14" is all you need.
Group related screenshots to tell a story: The message where they were skeptical, followed by the implementation, followed by the results creates a compelling narrative.
Always get permission: This should go without saying, but don't share private messages without explicit consent.

Check this newsletter I sent last month to see an example of how you can group related screenshots to tell a story:

4. Client success stories

Unlike before/after examples that focus on metrics and direct comparisons, success stories dive into the full, nuanced experience—the messy middle where the real transformation happens.

That messy middle looks like:

The previous failed attempts
The hesitation or skepticism
The moment of commitment
The unexpected challenges
The pivotal breakthroughs
The ripple effects beyond the initial goal

The anatomy of an irresistible client story:

The protagonist we recognize: "Sarah was a solo consultant who'd been stuck at $8K months for two years despite working 60-hour weeks. Every time she tried to raise her rates, she'd lose potential clients to cheaper alternatives."
The struggle that resonates: "She'd tried creating more content, offering additional services, even completely rebranding — but nothing moved the needle. She was considering giving up her business and returning to employment."
The turning point: "What finally changed everything wasn't adding more to her business — it was removing everything that wasn't essential to her unique expertise."
The journey details: "Over 90 days, we methodically identified her true zone of genius, eliminated three service offerings that were draining her energy, and completely restructured how she positioned her remaining services."
The concrete outcomes: "Within 4 months, her monthly revenue increased to $15K while working 15 fewer hours per week. More importantly, her close rate on sales calls went from 20% to 70% because she was only talking to ideal clients."
The deeper transformation: "The biggest change? Sarah says she no longer feels like she's constantly hustling to justify her value. Now, clients come to her specifically for her expertise — and they're happy to pay for it."

Client stories work because they go beyond the transactional aspects of your offer to show the transformational impact on a real person's life or business.

5. Implementation examples

One of the biggest barriers to buying is the gap between understanding a concept and actually applying it.

Why implementation proof converts skeptics:

It proves practicality: It shows your approach isn't just conceptually sound but actually implementable by real people.
It demonstrates flexibility: When you show multiple implementations, you illustrate how your approach adapts to different situations.
It answers the "but how?" question: It moves past the vague promise and into the concrete steps.
It pre-solves obstacles: Good implementation examples address the very roadblocks that prevent people from moving forward.

Ways to showcase implementation (that actually help people envision using your approach):

Document the adaptation process: "They took my framework and made these three specific changes to fit their industry..."
Show the work in progress: "Here's what their first draft looked like compared to the final version after applying the method..."
Highlight the decision points: "When they reached this stage, they had to choose between A and B. Here's why they went with A..."
Include the timeline: "From introduction to full implementation took 14 days. The first results appeared on day 7."

How to capture proof

Most people wait until they need proof (like when building a sales page) to frantically hunt for testimonials and results.

That's stressful AF.

Instead, create a systematic approach to capturing evidence:

Set proof capture triggers: Define specific moments in your client journey when you'll actively collect evidence. After their first win. At the halfway point. Upon completion. Three months later.
Create a "Wins Vault": Set up a dedicated space (Notion, Google Drive, your messy desktop, whatever works) where you immediately store every piece of proof you encounter. Screenshots of DMs, voice messages, emails — nothing is too small.
Ask questions that elicit usable proof: Skip "Did you enjoy working with me?" and ask, "What specific measurable results have you seen since implementing this framework?"
Encourage authentic documentation: Ask clients to take screenshots of their analytics, record quick videos sharing their wins, or snap photos of implementations.
Follow up strategically: Some of the best proof comes months after working together. Set reminders to check in with past clients for long-term results.

You got this.

Cheers,

Erica

PS. Speaking of proof...Full Stack Solo has been running for a few months now, and our members are seeing real, tangible results.

One member said, "I didn't realize just how stuck I was!" before making "more progress defining my go-to-market in two weeks than I saw in the six months prior."

And Sarah, who joined last week, said, "I'm only a day in, but it's already exactly what I needed."

It feels so good to launch something new into the world that's making a meaningful difference in people's lives. I love my job :)

In case you're unaware, Full Stack Solo is a codified 90-day program that guides you, step by step, to build a new offer, launch it into the market, and start selling immediately.

Oh, and we also now have payment plans. Woot!

Come join us and...

Simplify your offer so it's easy to sell 🏴‍☠️

PPS. People tell me all the time they're worried about sharing proof content because it's cringy or feels salesy.

Did my PS just now feel salesy, or like I'm genuinely keen to help struggling solos gain clarity and make more money?

I hope the latter, because that's my truth.

Lean into yours, and you really can't go wrong.